© Borgis - New Medicine 3/1999, s. 39-41
Andrzej Makowski, Agata Makowska-Piontek
Stapedectomy in children
Department of Otolaryngology, Institute of the „Polish Mother´s Hospital”, Łódź
Head of the Dep.: Ass. Prof. Andrzej Makowski, M.D.
Introduction
Stapedectomy in children has aroused much controversy regardless of its specific motivation, whether a fixed stapes is operated on because of a developmental anomaly, otosclerosis, or injury. J.W. House and co-workers (3) began their 1980 report on this subject with the words: „Stapedectomy on a child? Never! But we believe there are indications”, whereas B. Teunissen and co-workers (4, 5) are of the opinion that children who qualify for stapedectomy can be operated upon on certain conditions: 1. They must be over 10 years of age at the time of operation. 2. They must be free for any length of time from episodes of otitis media secretoria. 3. The procedure must be preceded by tone and speech audiometry, and by contralateral stapedial reflex examination. 4. In children with hypoacusis of the mixed type, a CT scan of the temporal bones should be performed. According to H.P. House (1, 2), unilateral hypoacusis caused by congenital stapes fixation does not require operative treatment, but bilateral hypoacusis must be corrected surgically by the time the child attends school.
Material and method
In the period from 1993 to 1998 24 children (32 ears) aged 5-16 years, with congenital malformations of the auditory ossicles were operated in the Department of Otolaryngology. The medical history of all the patients met the criteria of congenital hypoacusis proposed by House (2). The children presented with the following features: 1. distinct conduction hypoacusis from infancy, 2. unprogressive hypoacusis with a stable hearing level, 3. a typical audiogram with an air conduction curve of -50 to 60 dB with an accompanying bone conduction curve of 0-10 dB. None of the children was afflicted with chronic inflammatory conditions of the ears nor suffered from head injury in the past. Among 32 operated ears with developmental anomalies of the auditory ossicles, in 21 ears the malformations related to the stapes and the oval window. In 12 ears an isolated form of stapes fixation was reveałed at operation without distinct malformations of the malleus and the incus. In 4 ears an immobile stapes was more or less deformed (a monocrural stapes, a stapes with thick crura devoid of an opening, a stapes with delicate elongated crura), in 3 ears stapes and oval windows were missing, and in 2 cases there was an immobile stapes with missing incudostapedial joint (Table 1). In 15 patients (11 girls and 4 boys, 21 ears) various types of stapedectomias were performed. In 10 ears the surgical „small window” technique was employed, in 5 ears a prothesis suspended after stapedectomy on a long crus of the incus was grounded on the fatty tissue closing the oval window, and in 1 case transposition of a deformed incus was performed. In the remaining 5 ears TORP prostheses were used and grounded on the fatty tissue closing the newly formed window into the vestibule. In patients with stapes malformations, the first and second branchial arch syndrome was identified twice, proximal symphalangism once, frontometaphyseal dysplasia once, Klippel-Feil syndrome once, and incomplete Mohr´s syndrome once. In all the patients, prior to their qualification for the surgical procedure, a CT scan of the temporal bones was performed in order to exlude developmental anomalies of the inner ear. Assessment of hearing before and after operation was based on tone audiometry by determination of the arithmetical mean, median and standard deviation of the air and bone conduction thresholds for four frequencies: 500, 1000, 2000, 4000 Hz. The results obtained were elaborated statistically using the T-Student or Wilkcoxon´s tests.
Table 1. Intra-operative morphological changes in the ears with „minor” developmental anomalies - „aplasia minor”.
Case No | Sex | Age | Morphological changes | Type of procedure | Notes |
1 | F | 15 | Lack of stapes and oval window. Incus-long, wide, short crus. | Formation of window into vestibule. Incus-stapes prosthesis grounded on fatty tissue. | |
2 | F | 11 | Re-Lack of long crus of incus. Stapes base fixation. | Stapedectomy. Malleovestibulopexis TORP prosthesis grounded on fatty tissue. | Mohr´s syndrome |
3 | M | 6 | Le-Lack of long crus of incus. Lack of stapes. | Fenestration in vestibular fossula. Incudovestibulopexis. PORP prosthesis. | Klippel-Feil syndrome |
4 | F | 7 | Le-Stapes fixed by osseous thickening of its base. | Stapedotomy "small window". Teflon piston operation. | |
5 | F | 15 | Re-Lack of incudostapedial joint. Immobile, deformed stapes (thick crura, lack of opening between crura). | Stapedectomy. Malleovestibulopexis TORP prosthesis grounded on fatty tissue. | Frontometaphyseal dysplasia. Mitral valve leaflet prolapse. Gusher syndrome after operation. |
6 | F | 5 | Le-Deformation of malleus and incus, accretion to superior tympanic cavity i I wall. Stapes base fixation. | Le-Release of osseous ossicular accretions. Stapedectomy. Incus-stapes prosthesis grounded on fatty tissue. | |
7 | F | 16 | Le and Re-Stapes base fixation | Le and Re-Stapedotomy ("small window"). Teflon piston operation. | |
8 | F | 14 | Re-Stapes: hidden under facial canal. Osseous accretion of posterior crus to canal. Immobile base. Le-Stapes base fixation. | Re-Stapedectomy. Incus-stapes prosthesis grounded on fatty tissue. Le-Stapedectomy. Incus-stapes prosthesis grounded | |
9 | M | 9 | Le-Stapes fixed by osseous accretion to posterior tympanic cavity wall and by immobile base | Le-Stapedotomy ("small window"). Teflon piston operation | Dysostosis mandibulofacialis. Congenital paralysis of right facial nerve. Aplasia of right ear. |
10 | F | 8 | Le and Re-Stapes base fixation. | Le and Re-Stapedotomy. Teflon piston operation. | |
11 | F | 9 | Le-Lack of incudostapedial joint. Stapes monocrural immobile. Re-Stapes: lack of opening between crura, base fixation. | Le-Stapedectomia. TORP prosthesis grounded on fatty tissue. Re--Stapedectomia. Malleovestibu-opexis. TORP prosthesis grounded on fatty tissue. | "The 1 and 2"" branchial arch syndrome." |
12 | F | 8 | Le-Lack of Deformation of incus. stapes. Re-Lack of incudostapedial joint. Lack of long crus of incus. Stapes with delicate crura and with immobile base. | Le-Vestibulotomy. Malleovestibulopexis. TORP prosthesis. Re-Stapedotomy ("small window"). Incus transposition. | |
13 | M | 14 | Le-Stapes base fixation. | Le-Stapedectomy. Incus-stapes prosthesis grounded on fatty tissue. | Congenital ankylosis of stapes also on the right side. Gusher syndrome after stapedectomy. |
14 | M | 13 | Le and Re-Stapes base fixation. Re-Stapes base fixation. | Le and Re-Stapedotomy ("small window"). Teflon piston operation. | Proximal symphalangism |
15 | F | 14 | Re-Stapes base fixation. | Re-Stapedotomy ("small window"). Teflon operation. Piston | |
F - female Re - right ear
M - male Le - left ear
F - female Re - right ear
Results
The state of hearing of children before operation (theair conduction threshold) was at a level of 57.32ą8.57dB with a range of (min.-max.) 42.5-72.5 dB, Me =57.5 dB, and 10 ą 5 dB for bone conduction. After surgical treatment hearing acuity for air conduction was at a level of 35.65 ą 15.11 dB. Within a month of stapedectomy, a hearing improvement of 21.7 ą 10 dB was gained. After six months the state of hearing remained at a level of 34.7ą13.07 dB with a range of (min.-max.) 18.75-72 dB, Me = 30 dB, the gain being 22.6 ą 9.7 dB (Table 2). In two cases (patients No 5 and No 13, Table 1) a massive outflow of perilymph occurred during stapedectomy (the gusher syndrome) without sensorineural hearing impairment, and it subsided spontaneously after 3 days. In level of 28.5 ą 6.71 dB, and so the gain was 25.38ą5.68 dB, the improvement of hearing being statisticaly significant, p < 0,001. Conversationally serviceable hearing was gained in most of the children after stapedectomy, and in only two cases the patients had to continue to use hearing aids.
Table 2. State of hearing of children with developmental anomalies of auditory ossicles.
Case No | Sex | Age | State of hearing before operation ACC: 500Hz, 1, 2, 4 kHz | State of hearing 6 weeks after operation ACC: 500 Hz, 1,2, 4 kHz | State of hearing 6 months after operation ACC: 500Hz,1,2,4 kHz |
1 | F | 15 | 60-60-75-70 | 30-30-45-40 | 30-30-45-45 |
2 | F | 11 | 50-50-45-40 | 20-20-25-25 | 35-35-35-30 |
3 | M | 6 | 60-65-55-50 | 45-40-35-30 | 50-50-50-50 |
4 | F | 7 | 65-65-60-55 | 45-40-40-40 | 45-40-45-40 |
5 | F | 15 | 80-80-70-50 | 60-60-40-40 | 60-60-40-40 |
6 | F | 5 | 70-65- 65-70 | 70-85-65-70 | 35-30-35-40 |
7 | F | 16 | Le: 50-50-45-35 Re: 50-50-45-25 | Le: 25-25-20-20 Re: 30-30-25-30 | Le:25-10-15-10 Re: 30-25-25-35 |
8 | F | 14 | Le: 50-45-40-35 Re: 60-55-50-40 | Le: 20-20-30-40 Re: 30-30-30-30 | Le: 20-25-25-40 Re:30-30-30-30 |
9 | M | 9 | 70-70-70-80 | 70-70-70-80 | 70-70-70-80 |
10 | F | 8 | Le: 60-55-55-60 Re:60-55-55-60 | Le: 25-25-25-20 Re: 30-30-30-25 | Le: 25-20-25-25 Re: 30-30-30-25 |
11 | F | 9 11 | Le: 70-60-60-40 Re: 60-55-55-60 | Le: 20-15-15-25 Re: 30-30-30-25 | Le: 20-20-15-20 Re: 30-30-30-30 |
12 | F | 8 | Le: 65-65-60-50 Re: 65-65-55-55 | Le: 50-45-30-25 Re: 45-50-40-30 | Le: 50-45-30-25 Re: 45-50-40-35 |
13 | M | 14 | 55-55-50-45 | 25-25-25-30 | 25-20-20-30 |
14 | M | 13 | Le:
70-70-65-45 Re: 65-45-50-50 | Le: 40-40-35-35 Re: 30-30-30-30 | Le: 40-40-35-35 Re: 30-30-30-30 |
15 | F | 14 | 50-45-50-50 | 20-15-20-20 | 20-15-20-20 |
F - female Re - right ear
M - male Le - left ear
F - female Re - right ear
Discussion
Stapedectomy in children and in adolescents is a rarely performed procedure. Reports in the literature have warned of its possible after-effects caused by episodes of chronic exudative otitis media frequently encountered in school children (4, 5). It is therefore advised that stapedectomy be posponed until the second decade of the child´ s life. We know from our own experience based on the operative treatment of children with developmental anomalies of the ears that stapedectomy with vestibulan fenestration procedure constitutes only a slight danger of subsequent labyrinthitis. In our own material this complication did not develop, presumably because the operated children were under permanent laryngological care, and all causative agents that might lead to the development of eustachitis were excluded or treated prior to stapedectomy. Hearing improvement with a gain of conversational hearing level achieved after stapedectomy or vestibule fenestration in over 80% of cases is of tremendous benefit to the operated. There is no need for the child to use a hearing aid in the school environment, and this advantage prevails against the risk of complications, the number of which can be minimized under regular care on an out-patient basis.
Piśmiennictwo
1. House H.P.: Diagnostic aspects of congenital ossicular fixation. Trans. Am. Acad. Ophthalmol. Otolaryngol., 1956, 6, 787. 2. House H.P.: Congenital fixation of the stapes footplate. Otolaryngol. Clin. North. Am., 1969, 3. House J.W. et al.: Stapedectomy in children. Laryngoscope, 1980, 90, 1 l, 1804. 4. Teunissen B. et al.: Isolated Congenital Stapes Ankylosis: Surgical Results in 32 Ears and a Review of the Literature. Laryngoscope, 1990, 100, 12, 1331. 5. Teunissen B., Cremers C.W.R.J.: Surgery for congenital stapes ankylosis with an associated congenital ossicular chain anomaly. Int. J. Pediatr. Otorhinolaryngol.,1991, 21, 3, 217.
Pozostałe artykuły z numeru 3/1999: